do-humans-have-feelings
Original: do-humans-have-feelings on Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Transcript
Panel 1:
Robot: Do you think humans really have feelings, or are they just programmed to act like they do?
Large alien creature: Programming, obviously.
Panel 2:
Large alien creature: Robots are created all at once, designed to experience pure emotional states, just for the sake of having them.
Panel 3:
Large alien creature: Humans were designed by evolution to USE emotions to make heuristic decisions and manipulate other social beings.
Panel 4:
Robot: But they really THINK they're feeling emotions.
Large alien creature: Uh huh.
Panel 5:
Large alien creature: You know how you feel bad whenever someone dies?
Robot: Of course. Every second or so.
Panel 6:
Large alien creature: Humans only feel bad when humans they know die. Especially ones who are kin.
Panel 7:
Large alien creature: Genetic programming coupled to CPU resource maximization.
Robot: Bingo.
Votey:
Large alien creature: It's OK to tell them since they're incapable of sadness.
Robot: Do you think humans really have feelings, or are they just programmed to act like they do?
Large alien creature: Programming, obviously.
Panel 2:
Large alien creature: Robots are created all at once, designed to experience pure emotional states, just for the sake of having them.
Panel 3:
Large alien creature: Humans were designed by evolution to USE emotions to make heuristic decisions and manipulate other social beings.
Panel 4:
Robot: But they really THINK they're feeling emotions.
Large alien creature: Uh huh.
Panel 5:
Large alien creature: You know how you feel bad whenever someone dies?
Robot: Of course. Every second or so.
Panel 6:
Large alien creature: Humans only feel bad when humans they know die. Especially ones who are kin.
Panel 7:
Large alien creature: Genetic programming coupled to CPU resource maximization.
Robot: Bingo.
Votey:
Large alien creature: It's OK to tell them since they're incapable of sadness.
Alt text
A seven-panel comic in which a small grey robot and a large grey alien-like creature with a big eye discuss whether humans have real feelings. The robot asks if humans really have feelings or are just programmed to act like it; the creature says "Programming, obviously." The creature explains that robots are created all at once, designed to experience pure emotional states for their own sake, while humans were designed by evolution to USE emotions to make heuristic decisions and manipulate other social beings. The robot protests that humans really THINK they're feeling emotions, and the creature agrees with a flat "Uh huh." The creature asks the robot, "You know how you feel bad whenever someone dies?" and the robot replies, "Of course. Every second or so." The creature notes that humans only feel bad when humans they know, especially kin, die: "Genetic programming coupled to CPU resource maximization." The robot concludes, "Bingo." The joke inverts the usual question of whether robots have real feelings, casting robots as the emotionally genuine beings and humans as the merely-programmed ones. Votey: A close-up of the large creature's big eye as it says, "It's OK to tell them since they're incapable of sadness" — implying the humans being discussed can't be hurt by the verdict.
Transcribed by Claude Opus 4.8.