Protocol
Original: Protocol on Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Transcript
Caption box (top): I took the worst performing students on the last exam and assigned them a new test for the following week. In the intervening days, I smeared their foreheads with peanut butter and smooshed googly eyes into it.
Speech bubble (off-panel questioner): The result?
Man with blue hair and round glasses: Statistically significant improvement in their average score.
Man with blue hair and round glasses: The googly-goo protocol is VALIDATED and is now being trialed in thousands of public schools.
[He gestures with a piece of chalk toward a chalk drawing of a smiley face with googly eyes and a rising line graph, with axes labeled "score" (vertical), "time" (horizontal), and an arrow pointing "up."]
Bottom caption: Science pro tip: you can prove anything you want using regression to the mean.
Votey:
Speech bubble (a grinning man): We can create brand new medicines just by finding currently sick people and giving them whatever we like!
Speech bubble (off-panel questioner): The result?
Man with blue hair and round glasses: Statistically significant improvement in their average score.
Man with blue hair and round glasses: The googly-goo protocol is VALIDATED and is now being trialed in thousands of public schools.
[He gestures with a piece of chalk toward a chalk drawing of a smiley face with googly eyes and a rising line graph, with axes labeled "score" (vertical), "time" (horizontal), and an arrow pointing "up."]
Bottom caption: Science pro tip: you can prove anything you want using regression to the mean.
Votey:
Speech bubble (a grinning man): We can create brand new medicines just by finding currently sick people and giving them whatever we like!
Alt text
A man with blue hair and round white-rimmed glasses, holding a piece of chalk, explains his research. A caption reads that he took the worst-performing students on the last exam, retested them the following week, and in between smeared their foreheads with peanut butter and smooshed googly eyes into it. Asked "The result?", he says there was statistically significant improvement in their average score, declaring the "googly-goo protocol" VALIDATED and now being trialed in thousands of public schools. Beside him is a chalk sketch of a googly-eyed smiley face and a line graph of score rising over time. The bottom caption reads: "Science pro tip: you can prove anything you want using regression to the mean." The joke is that the worst scorers were always going to improve toward the average on a retest regardless of the silly intervention. Votey: a grinning man enthusiastically says, "We can create brand new medicines just by finding currently sick people and giving them whatever we like!" — applying the same flawed regression-to-the-mean logic to medicine.
Transcribed by Claude Opus 4.8.