Real
Original: Real on Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Transcript
Panel 1:
Fairy: AND NOW, BY MY MAGIC, YOU SHALL BE... A REAL BOY!
Panel 2:
Boy: WHAT WAS I BEFORE?
Panel 3:
Fairy: YOU HAD THE OUTWARD MANNER OF A CONSCIOUS BEING, BUT NO INTERNAL CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE.
Panel 4:
Boy: A PHILOSOPHICAL ZOMBIE
Panel 5:
Boy: THAT'S INCOHERENT. I WAS PRECISELY REPRODUCING THE STATEMENTS OF A BEING WITH RICH EXPERIENCE WITHOUT ANYTHING GOING ON INSIDE? IT DOESN'T EVEN MAKE *COMPUTATIONAL* SENSE. WHAT RESOURCES GENERATED THE APPARENTLY CONSCIOUS—HEY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
Panel 6:
(The fairy waves her wand, blasting magic at the boy.)
Panel 7:
(The boy stares, wide-eyed, transformed.)
Votey:
Boy (thought bubble): SUCKS BEING A DETERMINISTIC STIMULUS-REPONSE MACHINE.
Fairy: AND NOW, BY MY MAGIC, YOU SHALL BE... A REAL BOY!
Panel 2:
Boy: WHAT WAS I BEFORE?
Panel 3:
Fairy: YOU HAD THE OUTWARD MANNER OF A CONSCIOUS BEING, BUT NO INTERNAL CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE.
Panel 4:
Boy: A PHILOSOPHICAL ZOMBIE
Panel 5:
Boy: THAT'S INCOHERENT. I WAS PRECISELY REPRODUCING THE STATEMENTS OF A BEING WITH RICH EXPERIENCE WITHOUT ANYTHING GOING ON INSIDE? IT DOESN'T EVEN MAKE *COMPUTATIONAL* SENSE. WHAT RESOURCES GENERATED THE APPARENTLY CONSCIOUS—HEY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?
Panel 6:
(The fairy waves her wand, blasting magic at the boy.)
Panel 7:
(The boy stares, wide-eyed, transformed.)
Votey:
Boy (thought bubble): SUCKS BEING A DETERMINISTIC STIMULUS-REPONSE MACHINE.
Alt text
A seven-panel SMBC comic. A blue fairy with a wand tells a small boy, "And now, by my magic, you shall be... a real boy!" The boy asks, "What was I before?" The fairy answers, "You had the outward manner of a conscious being, but no internal conscious experience." The boy replies, "A philosophical zombie." He then objects at length: "That's incoherent. I was precisely reproducing the statements of a being with rich experience without anything going on inside? It doesn't even make computational sense. What resources generated the apparently conscious—hey, what are you doing?" The fairy, ignoring his philosophical argument, blasts him with magic from her wand. In the final panel the boy stares blankly, wide-eyed, now transformed. Votey aftercomic: a close-up of the boy's wide-eyed face with a thought bubble reading, "Sucks being a deterministic stimulus-response machine." The joke: the fairy turning him "real" actually made him a mindless deterministic machine, the opposite of conscious.
Transcribed by Claude Opus 4.8.