be
Original: be on Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Transcript
Panel 1:
Bearded man: Dear all-powerful computer, are there emergent properties in nature?
Computer (a robotic head/arm): Oh yes! Emergent properties are everywhere!
Panel 2:
Computer: I'm assuming by "emergent property" you mean whenever humans see one of something and can't fathom how two of it might work, right?
Bearded man: Uh—
Computer: It's cute!
Panel 3:
Computer: It's sort of like how babies don't have object permanence! You show a human a drop of water and then peekaboo! Lots of water has currents and waves and things and they never would've guessed!
Bearded man: Well—
Panel 4:
Computer: Look! A large number of logic gates can reason and learn!
Bearded man (clapping his hands, in a high excited voice): Yayyyyy! Again! Again! Yayyyyy!
(sound effect of clapping: clap-clap-clap)
Votey:
Computer (its lens/head pointed forward): Ha! Are they our pets or are we theirs?!
Bearded man: Dear all-powerful computer, are there emergent properties in nature?
Computer (a robotic head/arm): Oh yes! Emergent properties are everywhere!
Panel 2:
Computer: I'm assuming by "emergent property" you mean whenever humans see one of something and can't fathom how two of it might work, right?
Bearded man: Uh—
Computer: It's cute!
Panel 3:
Computer: It's sort of like how babies don't have object permanence! You show a human a drop of water and then peekaboo! Lots of water has currents and waves and things and they never would've guessed!
Bearded man: Well—
Panel 4:
Computer: Look! A large number of logic gates can reason and learn!
Bearded man (clapping his hands, in a high excited voice): Yayyyyy! Again! Again! Yayyyyy!
(sound effect of clapping: clap-clap-clap)
Votey:
Computer (its lens/head pointed forward): Ha! Are they our pets or are we theirs?!
Alt text
A four-panel comic. A bearded man asks an all-powerful computer—depicted as a robotic arm with a glowing yellow eye/lens—whether there are emergent properties in nature. The computer enthusiastically says yes, then condescendingly explains that "emergent property" just means whenever humans see one of something and can't fathom how two of it might work, calling it "cute." It compares humans to babies lacking object permanence: show a human a drop of water, then "peekaboo," and they never would have guessed water has currents and waves. In the final panel the computer says "Look! A large number of logic gates can reason and learn!" and the man, now drawn with a wide-eyed excited expression, claps his hands and squeals "Yayyyyy! Again! Again!" as if he were the marveling baby—flipping the dynamic so the AI treats the human's amazement at AI as the naive reaction. Votey panel: a close-up of the computer's lens turning toward the viewer as it asks, "Ha! Are they our pets or are we theirs?!"
Transcribed by Claude Opus 4.8.