trolley-realism
Original: trolley-realism on Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Transcript
Panel 1:
Unseen narrator/presenter (speech bubble): "YOU ARE IN A TROLLEY. BY ALTERING THE COURSE OF THE TROLLEY YOU CAN REDUCE OVERALL HARM. HOWEVER, IT WOULD CAUSE YOU MILD INCONVENIENCE AND ANYWAY YOU'RE ONLY HALF PAYING ATTENTION BECAUSE SOMETHING JUST HAPPENED ON YOUR PHONE."
A person with curly dark hair and round glasses, wearing a turtleneck and jacket, stands looking off to the side, gesturing vaguely with one hand.
Caption (below panel): Somehow the realistic version of the trolley problem was far more distressing.
Votey:
A person (drawn as a simple sketchy face with glasses) says: "AS LONG AS I'M NOT IN THE TROLLEY WHEN IT HITS, I FIND I JUST DON'T REALLY CARE."
Unseen narrator/presenter (speech bubble): "YOU ARE IN A TROLLEY. BY ALTERING THE COURSE OF THE TROLLEY YOU CAN REDUCE OVERALL HARM. HOWEVER, IT WOULD CAUSE YOU MILD INCONVENIENCE AND ANYWAY YOU'RE ONLY HALF PAYING ATTENTION BECAUSE SOMETHING JUST HAPPENED ON YOUR PHONE."
A person with curly dark hair and round glasses, wearing a turtleneck and jacket, stands looking off to the side, gesturing vaguely with one hand.
Caption (below panel): Somehow the realistic version of the trolley problem was far more distressing.
Votey:
A person (drawn as a simple sketchy face with glasses) says: "AS LONG AS I'M NOT IN THE TROLLEY WHEN IT HITS, I FIND I JUST DON'T REALLY CARE."
Alt text
An SMBC comic about a cynical, realistic take on the trolley problem. Main panel: a person with curly dark hair, round glasses, and a turtleneck stands looking distractedly to the side. A large speech bubble presents the scenario: "You are in a trolley. By altering the course of the trolley you can reduce overall harm. However, it would cause you mild inconvenience and anyway you're only half paying attention because something just happened on your phone." Caption below: "Somehow the realistic version of the trolley problem was far more distressing." The joke is that the classic ethics dilemma is reframed so the deciding factor is laziness and phone distraction rather than moral reasoning. Votey (aftercomic): a simply sketched face with glasses adds, "As long as I'm not in the trolley when it hits, I find I just don't really care" — punctuating the self-interested apathy.
Transcribed by Claude Opus 4.8.